2018 Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Betting Preview, Odds and Picks

By in Entertainment on

On July 4th, not only will we be celebrating America’s Independence with fireworks and barbeques, but we’ll also be celebrating by witnessing superhuman feats – the carnivorous devouring of roughly 15 pounds of hotdogs in 10 minutes. In other words, next Wednesday, we’ll all be tuning in to watch the 2018 Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest televised live on ESPN 2.

America’s most popular competitive eating competitions returns to Coney Island, on the corner of Surf and Stilwell avenues, where it’s been held every year since the early 70’s. This year, the main storylines are whether or not another contestant can upset the reigning, defending champs: Joey Chestnut for the men and Miki Sudo for the women.

The Legend and History of Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest

The history of this competition is wrapped up in legends and lore that add a certain charm to a contest where you gorge yourself to the point of almost passing out. It was believed that the first contest was held in 1916 at Coney Island, and was to settle a dispute between 4 immigrants fighting over which one of them was the most patriotic. This legend permeated through local media over the decades and became the main origin story of Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest.

Another popular legend claims that this contest began in 1917, when Mae West’s dad challenged Eddie Cantor to a hot dog eating contest. Whether it’s 4 immigrants battling it out, or a Hollywood hot dog duel, there’s no records of either of these legends taking place.

The first recorded hot dog eating contest at Coney Island was in 1972. Since then, this contest has grown to world-wide fame with over 40,000 people attending each year and millions of people watching on TV. It wasn’t until 2011, that Nathan’s created an all-women division for the hot dog eating contest.

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Competition Rules

Since 1997, this world renowned contest has been sanctioned by a governing body known as Major League Eating (MLE). Only contestants under contract with MLE can participate in this famous contest. Throughout the years, the MLE has tinkered with the competition’s rules. As of today, the following is a list of the major competition rules according to Wikipedia:

  • The field includes up to 20 contestants
  • Contest is 10 minute longs
  • Contestants have to eat hot dogs and buns
  • Contestants can have water or other approved drinks during contest
  • Penalty cards can be assessed for infractions
  • Tie-breakers include a hot dog eat-off between competitors

What Do the Winners Get?

Over the years, the awards have changed for the contest winner. However, one award that has been a mainstay for the last few decades is the coveted bejeweled mustard yellow belt. Since 2011, the mustard belt has been given exclusively to the men’s winner and a newly created bejeweled pink belt has been given to the women’s winner. In addition to these belts, the following unconfirmed cash payouts are expected to be given to the Top 5 finishers in both the men’s and women’s divisions:

  • 1st place: $10,000
  • 2nd place: $5,000
  • 3rd place: $2,500
  • 4th place: $1,500
  • 5th place: $1,000

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Past Winners

I consider the modern era of competitive eating, especially this contest, to have begun in 2001, with the arrival of Takeru Kobayashi. With that said, here’s a list of the past men’s winners:

Year Past Men’s Winners # of Hot Dogs
2017 Joey Chestnut 72
2016 Joey Chestnut 70
2015 Matt Stonie 62
2014 Joey Chestnut 61
2013 Joey Chestnut 69
2012 Joey Chestnut 68
2011 Joey Chestnut 62
2010 Joey Chestnut 54
2009 Joey Chestnut 68
2008 Joey Chestnut 59
2007 Joey Chestnut 66
2006 Takeru Kobayashi 53¾
2005 Takeru Kobayashi 49
2004 Takeru Kobayashi 53½
2003 Takeru Kobayashi 44½
2002 Takeru Kobayashi 50½
2001 Takeru Kobayashi 50

As you can see, Kobayashi and Chestnut have combined to win 16 of the last 17 contests. Only Matt Stonie has been able to sneak in there and get a win (2015).

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Competition Women’s Contest

Here are the past winners for the women’s competition dating back to the inaugural contest in 2011:

Year Past Women’s Winners # of Hot Dogs
2017 Miki Sudo 41
2016 Miki Sudo 38½
2015 Miki Sudo 38
2014 Miki Sudo 34
2013 Sonya Thomas 36¾
2012 Sonya Thomas 45
2011 Sonya Thomas 40

Sonya “The Black Widow” Thomas won the first three contests before being dethroned by Miki Sudo in 2014. Since then, Sudo has gone on to win four straight women’s competitions.

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest: Men’s Odds

With nearly 20 contestants in the men’s competition, most sportsbooks only have odds listed for the top male competitive eaters. The following odds are courtesy of BetOnline:

  • Joey Chestnut (-500)
  • Carmen Cincotti (+450)
  • Matt Stonie (+700)
  • The Field (+700)

The Favorite

Joey “Jaws” Chestnut isn’t just the greatest hot dog eater in the world, the 34-yeard old is widely considered the greatest competitive eater of all time. Standing at 6’1”, Chestnut’s competition weight tends to come in around 230 pounds. He burst on the scene in 2007, when he defeated the 6-time hot dog eating champ Kobayashi. Chestnut would go on to win 8 straight competitions until a shocking loss in 2015 to Matt Stonie. Jaws would return to claim his throne in 2016 and successfully defend it in 2017 to earn his 10th mustard yellow belt. This year, Chestnut is a huge favorite over every other competitive eater in the world. Speaking of the world, Chestnut has held or currently holds 43 world eating records across a wide range of foods. A few of these impressive records include:

  • 5 pounds of burritos in 10 minutes
  • 182 chicken wings in 30 minutes
  • 141 hardboiled eggs in 8 minutes
  • 103 Krystal hamburgers in 8 minutes

The Betting Value

Matt Stonie at +700 provides some betting value considering his past success in this competition. The 26-year old shocked the world when he defeated Joey Chestnut for the 2015 mustard belt. He ended Joey’s reign of eight consecutive victories. Stonie consumed 62 hot dogs in his 2015 title win, compared to 60 by Chestnut.

In 2016, Stonie set out to defend his hot dog eating title, but was demolished by Chestnut who ate 70 hot dogs compared to Stonie’s 52. Last year, Stonie finished 3rd with 48 hot dogs. Carmen Cincotti finished second with 60 and Chestnut finished first with 72 (just 1 ½ hot dogs less than his world record).

Matt competes at a weight of around 130 pounds, which makes him much smaller than Chestnut. But, don’t let the size fool you. Stonie currently holds, or held, at least 13 world eating records according to MLE. Some of those records included:

  • 182 strips of bacon in 5 minutes
  • 5 pounds of birthday cake in 8 minutes
  • 10 pounds of spaghetti with sauce in 8 minutes
  • 255 peeps in 5 minutes

The Field

The Field comes in with +700 betting odds. This does not include last year’s runner up Cincotti who is a +450 odds to win this year. Cincotti believes he can dethrone Chestnut next week and cruised in his qualifier with 50 hot dogs. He’ll be right up there competing with Joey this year.

But, since this section is all about The Field, let’s take a look at one competitor who has the best shot from this group of contestants to make some noise. Geoffrey Esper consumed 45 hot dogs in his qualifier this year to enter into this contest again. Last year, Esper finished 4th with 44.5 hot dogs. His qualifier results prove that he’s made progress from last year and that he has a shot at placing in the Top 3. Some of Esper’s impressive eating accomplishments include:

  • 36 pepperoni rolls in 10 minutes
  • 29 Fortune Bay Indian Tacos in 8 minutes
  • 83 slices of John’s Incredible Pizza in 10 minutes

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest: Women’s Odds

If you thought the men’s betting odds were limited, the women’s odds are scarcer. Most oddsmakers, like BetOnline, have the defending champ’s odds and that’s it.

Miki Sudo to win: Yes (-475) or No (+350)

Sudo has won the last 4 women’s competitions and there’s no end to her reign in sight. Last year Sudo crushed the competition by eating 41 hot dogs. Michelle Lesco finished second with 32½ hot dogs and the former 3-time winner Sonya Thomas came in third with 30 hot dogs.

Miki is proving that she’s only getting better each year, which is scary for the competition. A look at her progress over the last four years:

  • 2017 – 41 hot dogs
  • 2016 – 38.5 hot dogs
  • 2015 – 38 hot dogs
  • 2014 – 34 hot dogs

This really is Sudo’s competition to lose. She’s at the top of her game, while her competition is inconsistent at best. Despite being an overwhelming favorite, there will be two competitors that will force Sudo to bring her best effort: Lesco and Thomas.

Lesco came in 2nd last year, and she’s already showing to being at the top of her game. Lesco won her qualifier by consuming 29 hot dogs, which was more than any other female competitor to win their qualifiers. Lesco has finished 4th or better since entering the women’s competitions in 2011.

Sonya Thomas is quite possibly the oldest competitor, but is also one of the best in women’s competitive eating history. The soon-to-be 51 year old came in 3rd last year with 30 hot dogs, which broke a string of three straight 2nd places. Her 2017 effort was also 5 hot dogs less than her 2016 effort. Thomas should never be taken lightly. Not only is she a 3-time winner, but she also holds the women’s all-time record with 45 hot dogs.

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Betting Props

In addition to betting on who will win the contest, there are some intriguing betting props to check out. The following are the two most popular betting props from online bookmakers:

Joey Chestnut total hot dogs eaten: 70.5

  • Over -150
  • Under +110

I’m going with the Over here. Last year, Chestnut ate 72 hot dogs at this contest. In 2016, he finished with 70 hot dogs consumed. Joey holds the world record with 73.5 total hot dogs. He’s also consumed 68 or more hot dogs on 3 different occasions. If he comes in at the top of his competitive eating game, then he should get at least 70.5 hot dogs. And, he’s going to need to hit this number because last year’s runner up Cincotti has already declared that he will eat at least 70 hot dogs this year.

Miki Sudo total hot dogs eaten: 40.5

  • Over -130
  • Under -110

This prop bet is a little bit more difficult to select. I’m going with the Over because I believe Sudo will hit at least 41 hot dogs this year, which is what she consumed last year. But, it’s going to be close. In 2015 and 2016, Sudo ate 38 hot dogs each year. Top competitor Sonya Thomas has consumed 40 or more hot dogs on three different occasions, including her record of 45. So, I expect at least 40 this year, most likely 41.5 to 42 for Sudo.

2018 Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Final Thoughts

This year’s competition will surely be exciting to watch. It’s one of the most grotesque, yet fun 10 minutes of television. I expect Sudo and Chestnut to retain their titles and keep those belts around their waists. The Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest is a great way to kick off your 4th of July festivities. Just don’t get too excited and try to have your own eating competition at your family BBQ. Remember, these are trained competitors.

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Betting Recap

  • Men’s Winner: Joey Chestnut (-500)
  • Women’s Winner: Miki Sudo (-475)
  • Betting Value: Matt Stonie (+700)
  • Chestnut total hot dogs: Over 70.5 (-150)
  • Sudo total hot dogs: Over 40.5 (-130)

Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest Fun Facts

For those die hard hot dog eaters, the following is a list of fun facts for the Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest:

  • Since 2008, the length of the contest has been set at 10 minutes.
  • Joey Chestnut holds the record for most consecutive wins at 8.
  • Chestnut also holds the record for most career wins at 10.
  • Miki Sudo holds the women’s record for most career wins at 4.
  • Sudo also holds the women’s record for most consecutive wins at 4.
  • Sonya Thomas holds the women’s record by eating 45 total hot dogs.
  • The first women’s competition was held in 2011.
  • Sonya Thomas has the highest female ranking in the open competition (prior to 2011) with a 4th place ranking. (This doesn’t include contests from the 70’s and 80’s.)
  • Vomiting is against the rules and will get you disqualified.
  • In 2010, a banned Kobayashi tried to jump the fence and get on stage. He was arrested, but the charges were eventually dropped.
  • Chestnut consumed more than 21,000 calories in the 2017 competition.
  • ESPN has been airing the competition live since 2004.
  • Each hot dog is just under 7 inches and each bun is roughly 6 inches.
  • There’s over 61,250 mg of sodium per 70 consumed hot dogs and buns.
  • There’s almost 1,500 carbs consumed per 70 hot dogs and buns.
  • Over 1,225 grams for fat are consumed per 70 hot dogs and buns.
Rick Rockwell

As a longtime freelance writer, avid sports fan, former athlete, and experienced sports bettor, Rick Rockwell has risen up the ranks at GamblingSites.org to become the self-professed "King of the Blog" in his first year with the site. ...

View all posts by Rick Rockwell
Email the author at: [email protected]